Take what works and leave the rest
Alcoholics Anonymous and its sister programs are among the most recommended services for addiction support across the country and in many other regions of the world. The program has a lot going for it, and many believe that this is a strong service with many benefits for recovering from substance abuse problems. However, there have also been some criticisms leveled against the program, and it has been suggested that it might not be for everyone. So, let’s take a look at the pros and cons of Alcoholics Anonymous and consider who might benefit from this program and who might not.
- It’s easily accessible
One of the biggest advantages of AA is that it is easily accessible. First, it is available in a lo of different countries across the world and in many cities and small towns as well. This means that there are likely chapters of the organization available for someone looking for support. If there are no meetings near the person, it is possible to organize them. Secondly, AA is for everyone and people are not required to pay to access the services, even if donations are encouraged. This might make it a more affordable option for those who might struggle financially.
- It creates a support network
AA’s main draw is that it helps create a support network between people who face similar challenges. They encounter others struggling with similar things and can find understanding and informed advice. Additionally, the AA system contributes to forming strong bonds between the attendants and encourages them to take responsibility for each other through the sponsorship system. Having social support can be highly beneficial, especially in cases where the person with addiction has become isolated from others or has been rejected by their other contacts. In some situations, the person might feel that others in their don’t understand them as well.
- It offers structure
AA has a lot of structure. It has the 12-steps system, structured meetings, and other features that help make the person’s life more structured. This creates an additional support for those struggling with substance abuse and helps them rely on this structure to make their lives more organized as well. It also has a clear set of guidelines and protocols that are followed in different groups, so the person might move and still benefit from the structure they are accustomed to.
However, the AA has also been criticized for some aspects. It’s worth noting that many people find that AA is helpful even if the system is not entirely aligned with their ideas, however, for some the cons may be more significant.
- It has religious undertones
AA was born as a Christian organization and the echoes of this origin can still be felt today. For instance, one very cited aspect is the need to acknowledge a higher power, which is a part of the proposed steps. While the steps do not specify the higher power, this focus on the spiritual might be a turn-off for people with atheistic religious beliefs or those whose beliefs conflict with the ideas.
- It might create a dependence on the system
Something that has been criticized in relation to AA is that it might foster a dependence on the system instead of on the substance. Some people become excessively involved in AA and it becomes the center of their support system to the expense of other aspects of their lives and development. AA promotes a view of addiction as something that is never overcome fully. While this view might be important to promote responsibility and accountability, some have argued that it also limites the options of the people who are part of the group and makes them dependent on AA throughout their lives.
- It can vary by group
AA is a group ran by the people within it, so its effectiveness and support can vary significantly depending on where it is and how it is handled. For example, there are groups with those who attend AA by court order and are not significantly invested in being where, which might hurt the overall atmosphere if not properly addressed. Some AA meetings also are used unethically by people looking to sell drugs or for vulnerable people to hook up with. In many groups, this is effectively addressed but not always.
Overall, AA has helped a lot of people but, as anything, it has its pros and cons. For some, the cons may be more significant but it’s worth giving it a shot anyway. If you need help getting plugged into support groups or may be thinking about the idea of a sober house, call Valley Spring to find out exactly how they can help you get sorted with different recovery services and sober living in nyc.
Feel free to read our previous blog about if alcohol should be banned